|
genderequalitygoals
genderequalitygoals
Friday, 20 November 2026
Restorying Autism Webinar Recording!
The Ruin RIOC Won’t Talk About
The Ruin RIOC Won’t Talk AboutFriends of the Ruin met with RIOC in July about the Smallpox Hospital’s future. RIOC still hasn’t said what it plans.
The Renwick Smallpox Hospital has been moldering as a ruin on the southern tip of Roosevelt Island for decades. Though it has been a New York City Landmark since 1976 and is on the National Register of Historic Places, it continues to remain obscure outside of Roosevelt Island when compared to some of the city’s other prominent landmarks. For years, there has been talk of turning it into a public park, akin to Europe’s Gothic cathedral ruins open to the public. However, for the past decade, all such plans have stalled, and the ruin remains off-limits (unless you’re an urban explorer). [Editor’s note: State grant records show public planning money for the ruin in 2015, 2018 and 2024. See “Editor’s Note: What the Record Shows” below.] The Friends of the Ruin, the nonprofit hoping to turn the hospital into a public park, met with the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation in July of 2026 to discuss the ruin’s future. “Our July convening brought together organizations from Roosevelt Island and advocacy groups from across New York City to discuss the building’s history, its significance, and its potential future as public space,” said Stephen Martin. Martin is the founder and board president of Friends of the Ruin. He is also an architect and former director of design and planning at Four Freedoms Park Conservancy. Martin added, “The meeting was an important first step. We want residents to have a meaningful role in shaping the conversation about the ruin and its future. There is an opportunity to preserve an extraordinary historic structure while creating a place that serves the island and speaks to the building’s history as a site of public health. We look forward to continuing these conversations with residents and community organizations.” The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation did not respond to requests for comment. It has sought state funding for stabilization design, but it has never stated whether it supports the Friends of the Ruin’s plans to turn the ruin into a park. The Friends of the Ruin recently gave their website a facelift. The new website contains more information about the hospital’s unique history and origins, as well as what it means in the context of a modern, post-COVID society. Martin spoke of their website’s facelift, saying of the ruin, “Its history feels particularly relevant in a post-COVID world. Designed by James Renwick Jr., the architect of St. Patrick’s Cathedral, it is also an important work of nineteenth-century architecture. The updated website brings these stories together and explains our efforts to stabilize the ruin and ultimately adapt it for public use.” The updated website now contains information about the history of smallpox (the first disease humanity has eradicated), James Renwick Jr., and the building’s backstory.
The Friends say that initial surveys estimated the cost of stabilizing the ruin, as well as additional work required to make its environs safe, would cost $29 million, according to Martin. (For reference, since its founding, the Friends have raised some $1.2 million as of 2022.) However, this is an earlier figure, and the Friends currently do not have an estimate for what it would cost today to totally transform the ruin; further surveys are needed, they say. Martin says, “We continue to pursue funding and build the partnerships necessary to move forward. Our goal remains to preserve the ruin and make it accessible to the public, though the timeline depends on funding, design development, and the necessary approvals…Our ongoing conversations with RIOC and the community are an important part of that effort.” [Editor’s note: The Friends did not give a date for the $29 million estimate. Earlier public figures include about $20 million (RIOC, 2018), $23 million (Martin to RIOC’s board, March 2021) and a $43.2 million capital goal (Friends of the Ruin, 2021). See below.] Editor’s Note: What the Record ShowsThis section was added by the LightHouse editor. It is not Paul Kemp’s writing, and he is not responsible for it. Landmark status and the leaseThe Smallpox Hospital was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on March 16, 1972 and designated a New York City Landmark on March 23, 1976. The ruin stands in Southpoint Park, on City-owned land leased to the State in 1969 and managed by RIOC since 1984. According to a 2003 audit by the New York City Comptroller, that lease requires RIOC to develop the island’s open spaces as parkland and to stabilize the landmarks in them. The approvals Martin mentionedMartin says the timeline depends on “the necessary approvals.” At least one of them involves Albany. RIOC is a public benefit corporation with a governor-appointed board, which makes it a “state agency” under the State Historic Preservation Act. Section 14.09 requires a state agency, before it approves a final design or funds a project, to notify and consult the State Historic Preservation Office whenever the work “may or will cause any change, beneficial or adverse,” to a National Register property. State regulations list restoration, rehabilitation and site improvements among those changes, so planned stabilization would qualify, as would a park. The statute exempts work needed to prevent an immediate threat to life or property. The State Historic Preservation Office comments on the plan and RIOC makes the final decision, and the office’s comment must be made available to the public on request. The City’s role is less clear. Asked about Blackwell House in 2001, a Landmarks Preservation Commission spokeswoman told The New York Observer that RIOC “is not required to adhere to our requirements.” We have not found a later public statement on whether the Commission would review work at the Smallpox Hospital. State grants and cost estimatesState grant records show three awards for planning work at the ruin over the past decade. In 2015, the State signed a $200,000 grant contract with the Four Freedoms Park LLC to study reusing the hospital. In 2017, RIOC applied for a $500,000 Environmental Protection Fund grant (CFA 73645) to produce design and construction documents for stabilizing the walls, parapets and masonry. The contract was executed November 1, 2018. The State now lists that project as complete, with $225,489 disbursed, or about 45 percent of the award. In 2024, Friends of the Ruin received its own $333,800 grant to finish design work. Nothing has been disbursed, and completion is expected in December 2027. The cost estimates have also changed over time. In 2018, RIOC’s then-president cited a schematic design report estimating stabilization at about $20 million. In March 2021, according to RIOC’s board minutes, Martin put it at $23 million. The Friends’ 2021 presentation set a $43.2 million capital goal for a broader project. We have not found a dated public source for the $29 million figure. RIOC’s proposed budget for fiscal year 2027-28, presented to its board on October 22, carries a capital line titled “Smallpox Hospital (Design).” It shows zero dollars in every year from FY 2025-26 through FY 2036-37. What the calendar showsIn response to a Freedom of Information Law request filed by the LightHouse (RIOC FOIL 2026-84), RIOC produced a redacted copy of President and CEO B.J. Jones’s calendar for July 13 to 19, 2026. Page 2 lists a 4 PM entry on Tuesday, July 14: “Friends of the Ruin + RIOC Follow Up,” in RIOC’s Conference Room 426.
The entry establishes that a meeting was scheduled. It does not show who attended, what was discussed or whether anything was decided. The words “Follow Up” suggest an earlier meeting, which falls outside the one-week period RIOC produced. The record also does not establish whether this is the “July convening” Martin describes, which he says brought together island organizations and citywide advocacy groups. RIOC’s obligations as a public authorityRIOC is a state public authority. It files reports under the Public Authorities Law, holds board meetings subject to the Open Meetings Law, and keeps records subject to FOIL. On July 6, RIOC said it was “honored” that the World Monuments Fund named the hospital one of ten “Irreplaceable America” sites. We have found no board resolution, budget narrative or public statement in which RIOC says what it plans for the building or whether it supports the Friends’ proposal. RIOC may have reasons to move carefully. The need is large and unfunded, its nonprofit partner is still raising money, and the estimates depend on how much work is in scope. Those are reasons to explain the plan to the public as it develops. Records that would answer the questionRIOC should already hold the records that would settle this: the drawings and reports produced under CFA 73645, along with the reason less than half the grant was drawn; any submission to, or comment from, the State Historic Preservation Office; any agreement, consent or letter of support given to Friends of the Ruin; any agenda and attendee list for July 14; and a board-level statement of whether RIOC supports public access to the ruin, and on what terms. New York State has seen some beautiful old buildings repurposed over the years. Untermyer Gardens in Yonkers was a dangerous ruin for decades, but it has since been turned into a glorious public garden for the people of New York to enjoy. The Domino Sugar Factory was once a place of industry; it has since seen its transformation into office space and housing be one of the Brooklyn Waterfront’s main success stories. Yet the Renwick Smallpox Hospital continues to rot away, in spite of what could be. The RIOC’s advertising asking tourists from the tramcar to linger on the island prominently features the Smallpox Hospital Ruins on its boards. The hospital itself is integrally tied to the history of the island and the island’s many uses over the years. Yet the RIOC remains clammed up on the ruin’s ultimate fate. Something is clearly in the works regarding the ruin, given the RIOC’s meeting with the Friends, but what exactly is unclear. Until the RIOC is more transparent about their dealings and plans for the ruin, it will continue to molder in silence, its ultimate fate unknown and obscure. This newsletter travels best hand to hand. If you know someone who would read this all the way through, they are probably who it is for. Pass it along. Some things on this Island have been behind a fence long enough. Subscribe for free to receive updates on new posts and support our work.
© 2026 Theo Gobblevelt
|
Restorying Autism Webinar Recording!
Catch up on what you missed last night! ...
-
Dear Reader, To read this week's post, click here: https://teachingtenets.wordpress.com/2025/07/02/aphorism-24-take-care-of-your-teach...






