Why Waiting a Year to Promote Someone is Stupid

Lee Nallalingham

May 1

Ever noticed how many organizations have a seemingly arbitrary rule about promotions? It's the idea that you have to wait a whole year before you can move up the ladder, regardless of how much value you're adding or how ready you are for more responsibility. But here's the thing: this outdated practice is not only frustrating for employees, but it's also costing companies valuable talent.

The Flaw in the Waiting Game

Imagine this scenario: You're excelling in your role, taking on more responsibilities, and delivering exceptional results. You're ready for the next challenge and eager to advance in your career. But when you approach your manager about a promotion, you're told to wait until the next annual review cycle. Sound familiar?

This practice of making employees wait a year for a promotion not only demotivates individuals but also creates a sense of disillusionment and disengagement. After all, why should top performers continue to go above and beyond when their efforts are not being recognized or rewarded in a timely manner?

The Cost of Delayed Recognition

The consequences of this "wait a year" mentality extend beyond employee morale. It's also a significant factor contributing to talent attrition. When individuals feel undervalued or underappreciated, they're more likely to seek opportunities elsewhere—often at organizations that offer more responsive and merit-based promotion policies.

Think about it: If an employee is already doing the job of a higher-level role, why should they have to wait for an arbitrary date on the calendar to be officially recognized and compensated accordingly? The longer organizations delay promotions, the more likely they are to lose their top performers to competitors who are willing to act swiftly and reward talent appropriately.

Rethinking Promotion Policies

So, what's the solution? It's time for organizations to reconsider their approach to promotions and embrace a more flexible and merit-based system. Instead of adhering rigidly to annual review cycles, companies should empower managers to recognize and reward exceptional performance in real-time.

By adopting a more agile approach to promotions, organizations can:

Retain Top Talent: Recognize and retain high-performing employees by rewarding their contributions in a timely manner, rather than making them wait for an arbitrary deadline.
Increase Engagement: Foster a culture of recognition and appreciation, where employees feel valued and motivated to continue exceeding expectations.
Drive Performance: Encourage continuous improvement and innovation by incentivizing employees to strive for excellence and pursue opportunities for growth and advancement.

By rethinking the traditional "wait a year" mentality and embracing a more agile and merit-based approach to promotions, companies can create a culture where excellence is recognized, rewarded, and celebrated in real-time.

So, isn't it time to leave the waiting game behind and usher in a new era of talent management?

Are you a HR Professional keen to learn how AI can benefit your day-to-day work? If so, sign up for my brand new online course Applying AI in HR: A Practical Guide for HR Professionals. Get straightforward insights into leveraging AI across all HR domains.

For just £99, gain unlimited access to 22 pre-recorded lessons on AI in HR, each under 20 minutes. Learn at your own pace and embark on a journey to mastering AI in HR.

Also, explore my international bestselling books:

Check out my podcast, "A Practical Guide to..." available on:

Thanks for your support!