On ATIP, the government should just move to automated translation as it is getting good enough to be used for ATIP. From a client service perspective, would address timeliness, from a government perspective, would address costs:
...In other bilingualism news, journalist Dean Beeby reports that federal official languages commissioner Raymond Théberge has launched an investigation into the CBC proactively posting online its responses to journalists' access-to-information requests.
That's an undisputed best practice in the world of access-to-information, a field in which Canada (and the CBC in particular) ranks somewhere below South Sudan and Myanmar: If you've released information to one journalist, there's no earthly reason to make other journalists request it again and go through the whole rigmarole. Just send them a link to the response, or they can find it themselves.
But federal government institutions are required to publish everything in French and English; the CBC's responses are in English. So now we have a federal appointee considering whether this rare attempt at transparency must be published in both official languages.
That would amount to thousands upon thousands of pages of documents. They absolutely will not be translated. The only practical outcome is not to publish the documents at all. I'm quite sure CBC would be happy with that.
And without getting too melodramatic about it — official bilingualism is totally sustainable, in a rational form — I feel like we're at a crossroads here. There was a time when Canada was fat and happy enough that doing arguably weird and excessive things in the name of official bilingualism didn't seem like too much of a burden or a hassle. We had plenty of money, debt-to-GDP was fine, pretty much everyone with a decent job had a decent place to live.
That time is not now. This is a broke and broken country, requiring generations of punishingly expensive fixing — not least on the most basic issue of housing — that actually made a controversy out of children's medicine delivered to Quebec, during a children's medicine shortage, on grounds the labels weren't bilingual.
It's enough, already. Someone just has to say it: "enough." But no one with the power to change anything ever, ever will.
No comments:
Post a Comment