Madlik Haggadah - Where Is the Stranger?The most repeated command in the Torah—and the most conspicuously absent voice at the Seder
Everybody asks why Moses is missing from the Haggadah. It’s a good question. But it might not be the most important one. Because if the Exodus story is meant to shape our moral imagination—
The Most Repeated CommandThe Torah commands us—again and again—to care for the stranger. Not once. According to the Rabbis: 36 times. 📖 Exodus 22:20
📖 Deuteronomy 10:19
If you have any doubts or wish to explore the centrality of loving the stranger I recommend the recent lecture by Rabbi Shai Held from Hadar Loving the Stranger-Sojourner (Ger) And Yet—At the Seder… SilenceWe tell the story of being strangers. And yet—
No dedicated section. Or Is He?At the very beginning, we declare:
It sounds universal. Open. Generous. But is this really the ger?
The Mishnah’s Forgotten EndingThe Mishnah gives us a roadmap for the Seder— It’s actually a very central part of the seder. Some would argue that it represents the Rabbi’s first choice from scripture to tell the story of the Exodus (Magid). Even by biblical critics, the verses chosen are certifiably ancient and has the added advantage of representing a seminal declaration known by most Israelites by heart. It is the Declaration of the Bikurim in Deuteronomy. The Mishnah in Pesachim 10:4
But we don’t. Because the end includes this: 📖 Deuteronomy 26:11
Why Was It Left Out?The Rabbis who shaped the Haggadah lived in exile. They could not complete the story. Our “traditional” Haggadah ignores the clear requirements of the Mishnah and ends with Deuteronomy 26:8
it emits the next verses … “until the end of the parsha”:
Giving the Rabbis the benefit of the doubt, they must have thought that ending with return, land, and shared prosperity— So they stopped short. But in the process they lost the punch line, they abandoned the Ger. Again, giving them the benefit of the doubt, the Jew in exile was at the bottom of the social pyramid and dealing with the stranger was not a realistic talking point. Now We Are Living the EndingToday, for the first time in two thousand years,
We are back in the land of Israel. Which means the part the Haggadah omits—
The Part We Can No Longer SkipThe Torah’s closing vision is clear:
We are now back in the land of Israel, especially in what was once called Yehuda and Shomron. And it must be said:
They celebrate the return—
The Real Test of RedemptionIt’s easy to tell the story. It’s harder to finish it. The Torah does not say: Remember that you were strangers. It says:
It’s time for all our co-religionists to follow the dictates of the Mishnah and read it until the end. Sefaria Source Sheet: https://voices.sefaria.org/sheets/229545
|
No comments:
Post a Comment